The Sin-Eater’s Confession by Ilsa Bick
Published: March 1st 2013 by Carolrhoda Books
Source: ARC from publisher
Synopsis: People in Merit, Wisconsin, always said Jimmy was . . . you know. But people said all sorts of stupid stuff. Nobody really knew anything. Nobody really knew Jimmy.
I guess you could say I knew Jimmy as well as anyone (which was not very well). I knew what scared him. And I knew he had dreams—even if I didn’t understand them. Even if he nearly ruined my life to pursue them.
Jimmy’s dead now, and I definitely know that better than anyone. I know about blood and bone and how bodies decompose. I know about shadows and stones and hatchets. I know what a last cry for help sounds like. I know what blood looks like on my own hands.
What I don’t know is if I can trust my own eyes. I don’t know who threw the stone. Who swung the hatchet? Who are the shadows? What do the living owe the dead?
My thoughts: This book had my heart racing and forced me to stay up late into the night turning the pages until I reached the end. It was darkly fascinating. I was spellbound.
Ben is now a medic in the Armed Forces serving in Afghanistan, but once, he was a driven teenager from rural Wisconsin with dreams of the Ivy League. Something happened his senior year that rocked his hometown and changed his life plans. Something that is weighing heavily on his soul, prompting him to write a letter explaining his part in the tragedy. Bick’s choice of this set-up rather than a straight narrative of the events is deliberate, and what made the story work for me. Ben’s voice as he explains to the reader and the recipient of the letter is one of someone who has frantically obsessed over these events. He’s convinced himself of what happened to the point where his truth is subjective. It recalled the same foreboding feeling I got reading Poe’s short stories for the first time. This narrator is unreliable, be sure. We get all of Ben’s internal thoughts and a front row seat to his justifications and decision-making process, but that makes them even more suspect. Bick’s background as a child psychologist is put to good use, because I feel immersed in Ben’s mind.
Ben befriends a younger boy, Jimmy, after his older brother dies and the family needs help on their farm. He milks cows ands hauls hay, and one afternoon, takes his sweaty shirt off and naps in the hay loft. Jimmy snaps a photograph of him that happens to be very sensual. The photo wins a national photography contest and appears in a magazine, and changes Ben and Jimmy’s lives forever.
I can attest that there are dark corners of this country in which people still think homosexuals should burn in hell, and this is the kind of town that Merit, Wisconsin is. It’s not even okay to be thought of as being tolerant of that sort of lifestyle, let alone be openly gay. I’m not one to want to put a blanket judgment on rural areas as small-minded and bigoted, but I don’t want to romanticize these picturesque country towns with their ultra-conservatives, either. I’ve lived it and witnessed it myself. Small towns can be mighty intolerant of those who are different, and Jimmy was definitely different. He’s an artist but a bit manipulative, though readers do not get to know him well and only see him through Ben’s eyes. As perfect as Ben had tried to construct his persona as a volunteer at the hospital who always got good grades, he was not a good person, he didn’t do the brave thing and stand up for his friend.
I think this is an important contribution to queer YA literature, because it takes a point-of-view that I haven’t seen done before. It’s not about coming out and it’s not a romance and it isn’t afraid to remind teens that were born the year that Matthew Shepherd was murdered that they were born into a world where that kind of hatred exists.
There are plenty of readers who won’t get on board with an unlikeable main character. They want a hero who may be conflicted, who may even have dark tendencies with which he must battle, but they still want a character who will make the right choice at the critical moment, who will save the day. I think it’s delightfully interesting to peek inside a character who is conflicted, who may have good intentions, but it still too selfish to do the right thing. That’s why I loved The Sin-Eater’s Confession, and many will not.
Reading Between Classes: “Firstly, the main character was despicable. He was unlikeable, cowardly and an all around lame-ass human being…The writing featured a great deal of conjecture in the main character’s head. This was boring. repetitive and, ultimately, pointless.”
Annette’s Book Spot: “The inner dialog is realistic and heartbreaking. Everything gets worse when he witnesses some violence and does nothing about it.”
In Bed With Books: ” It’s got a great voice and raises some interesting questions, but it’s pretty messy. Recommended for fans of unsolved mysteries and LGBTQ themes.”
8 thoughts on “A Different Kind of LGBTQ Book: The Sin-Eater’s Confession by Ilsa Bick”
Ilsa Bick … I have a love/”meh” relationship with her. I loved ASHES but couldn’t stand the second in the series (way too much head jumping, which completely broke away from the way she wrote ASHES). I liked DRAW THE DARK, but it was kind of dumb in parts. This book sounds like the same voice and tone as DRAW THE DARK — and also takes place in Wisconsin. I wonder why that state is always reoccurring in her writing. I’m going to read DROWNING INSTINCT — I’ve heard a lot of good things about it. If I like that, if she doesn’t mess it up with an annoyingly open ending, I’ll have to try this book. I love the idea and concept and always admire Bick’s ability to be dark. I really, really, really want to love Ilsa Bick since she can be so amazing at times but … I’m not sure. Great review. Thanks for putting this book on my radiar.
This was the first of hers I’ve read, though I have a signed copy of Ashes from YA lit symposium last year. I think she sets books in Wisconsin because she’s from there. Reviews on this have been pretty split as far as I could find, so it’s a love or hate book, but I really enjoyed it.
I honestly have no idea if I’ll love this book or if I won’t be able to stand it, but I’m now thoroughly convinced I want to read it. I love what you said about it being a Poe-like unreliable narration, and I’m also very interested to see the small-town reactions to Ben. I too am from a rural area (heck, I’m from where Matthew Sheppard happened if that gives any indication as to the attitudes I was surrounded by growing up), and I agree that they shouldn’t be blanketed one way or the other–there are bigots there, but also wonderful people…it’s just unfortunate that sometimes the louder crowd is the more destructive one. So intrigued by this one, thanks Molly!
This book was very intriguing…I hope you check it out! I’d like to see your take on it, good or bad.